Friday, September 04, 2009

Lulu Wonders If You Agree With Hishamuddin

"The bloggers made it seem that I fully supported the residents"
http://www.thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2009/9/4/nation/4649576&sec=nation


and if you dont have mkini subscription (rm150/year http://malaysiakini.com/) and are not able to watch it, Lulu has good news for you!
no.... am not offering free subscription, but Lulu painsakingly transcribed the video.

-Saya dapat duduk dan mendengar sendiri apa masalah dan perkara yang timbul berhubung kait dengan bantahan mereka, berhubung mengenai isu yang digebar-geburkan daan diketahui ramai.
-Saya nak maklumkan di sini bahawa Alhamdulillah, saya cukup gembira apabila saya mendengar bahawa bantahan mereka tidak ada pertimbangan politik langsung seperti ada kumpulan-kumpulan tertentu membuat tuduhan.
-Memang saya sendiri ada menyatakan sebelum ini kawasan yang telah ditentukan oleh kerajaan negeri Selangor tidak sesuai kerana majoriti penduduk tersebut merupakan orang Melayu Islam dan mereka telah membuat bantahan tetapi bantahan mereka tak didengari dan yang malangnya, memang betul bila kepala lembu digunakan memang cukup sensitif dan mereka yang mewakili penduduk menyatakan mereka tak berniat langsung, tidak ada perancangan langsung untuk menimbulkan dalam membawa kepala lembu sebagai satu perkara yang boleh mencetuskan sensitiviti kaum dan mewujudkan satu ketegangan.
-Kalau kita tidak mengambil tindakan yang bijaksana, kalau sekiranya kita nak mengapi-apikan keadaan, kalau sekiranya pertimbangan kita hanya kepada politik, dan kalau saya nak menggunakan ianya sebagai satu isu yang boleh mencetuskan huru hara di negeri Selangor, boleh, tetapi kita tidak mengambil tindakan yang sebegitu rupa tetapi pihak-pihak yang waras, yang bijaksana, yang sayang kepada negaranya dapat meluahkan protes mereka berkait dengan lokasi yang telahpun ditetapkan oleh kerajaan negeri Selangor dan sekarang ini mereka boleh duduk berbincang bersama mugkin mencari lokasi yang lebih sesuai menjadikan satu keadaan yang menang-menang.

-They don't even know the organisers who are sitting left and right of me that somebody was going to bring the head of a cow during the demonstration and there have also been cases where like i said earlier, pig heads have been used to inisight racial anger and if everybody takes a decision that an eye for an eye is the way out then everybody will end up blind.
-we have to investigate because i asked them, they dont know who it was and this is what happens when you have protest of this nature. in fact when they discussed about it, there may be a situation where they may not be able to control.
-so that is why when we talk about assembly, the right to speak, the right to protest in a country like ours, you always have to alwats be sensitive to the fact that this right that everybody is talking about may just turn into a wrong, where it will effect the right of the majority to safety and it may raise sensitive issues that may hurt and slight those of other races and religion.
-so that is where when we do look at ammendments, when we do give these extra rights for speech, to assemble, to protest, to demonstrate, not to the extent that it causes instability, it affects the safety and the harmony of Malaysian people who the majority of them are very sensible and peace loving people as you can see from what they have been doing in the last few days, and to be honest with you, i didn't know that they have been talking, and only when i came, i just came back from cabinet, and they brief me, i thought i want to go into more detail and see how i can assist them, but they have already actually reach some compromise, and i congratulate them.
-but it was not a big protest, i mean, in fact, they told me they were very respectful that the sultan of selangor is there, in fact they limited it to the number of 10 people from the committee.
-in fact if they wanted to have a bigger protest, they could have had. and they were concious of the fact.
-this is exactly what i asked them. and so what your concerns are, were the exact questions i posed to them. now, they were very concious, and all they wanted to do was to voice their unhappiness.
-the very people who want the isa to be dimansuhkan sekarang ini buat kenyataan kepada saya suruh saya tangkap dia orang ni dalam isa.
-logic ke tidak
-orang yang dulu ni nak mansuhkan isa, sekarang ini bila ia jadi kepada mereka, mereka tanya kenapa tidak ambil tindakan isa terhadap mereka.
-jadi, as a minister, how are you going to make a decision
perkara yang menyulitkan sekarang ialah bila hujah-hujah dan kenyataan-kenyataan dibuat di dalam cyberspace, di dalam internet, itulah sebabnya baru-baru ini, saya dengan datuk rais, datuk nazri telahpun duduk bersama meminta pihak IGP, pihak peguam negara dan pihak MCMC suruhanjaya multimedia untuk membantu supaya bila kita mengambil tindakan nanti ada bukti dan satu kes yang kukuh supaya bila dibawa ke mahkahmah, tidak akan lepas dari gengaman kita.

6 comments:

anonymous dud said...

“Do the right thing and be cursed than do the popular but wrong thing and be applauded”

–Tun Hussein Onn

Si Tampok Manggis said...

Ini kualiti Menteri BN, kenyataan dan pendirian flip-flop. Tak pikir panjang. Cakap ikut sedap mulut dan hanya bersesuaian dgn khalayak yang menjadi audience ketika itu. Ini menteri yang layak di gelar menteri sesumpah, yang lidah dan akalnya pendek.

Tapi kalau Najib pulak dia jawab 'nanti saya balik tanya penasihat saya. Saya perlukan fact and figure'

Dua- dua mangkokkk.

Rakyat perlu ambil iktibar dan bebaskan Malaysia dari pemimpin-pemimpin yang bodoh teramat sangat.

Anonymous said...

' ...the organisers din EVEN know there was a cow-head blooddddy there
.......!! '
' ....and the anti-ISA people want me to ISA the protesters ...how can ? '

Antares said...

My head immediately felt congested at the sight of the homo minister and my brain shut down, shorting the verbal circuitry... but I distinctly heard my buttocks go Prrrrp.

Anonymous said...

there are cases of using pig-head b4
....so...so...this time ..using cow-head , ...a...aa...fair & square laa ...!!!!

Anonymous said...

In law ignorance is no defence. If you have committed an offence and admit to it the next stage is punishment to fit the crime.Ramlax